ExplainersHomepage

Lands Ministry fails to respond to RTI request on Green Ghana initiative

The Forestry Commission has failed to comply with a request from the Ministry of Lands and Natural Resources to provide information on contracts awarded to local seedling suppliers in 2023 and 2024, as highlighted in a DUBAWA and Daily Graphic investigation.

The Chief Director of the Ministry, Innocent Marcus Haligah, wrote to the Forestry Commission requesting details to enable the sector ministry to provide this reporter with updated information on the Green Ghana Initiative.

However, nearly three months after the letter was sent, neither the Ministry nor the Forestry Commission has responded to the Right to Information (RTI) request seeking details of the implementation of the Green Ghana Initiative between 2021 and 2024.

Repeated requests for information on Green Ghana project 

On Aug. 18, 2026, the Daily Graphic submitted a request seeking detailed records on the project’s implementation, including the number of seedlings planted, their survival rates, expenditure, procurement processes and post-planting maintenance.

It also sought explanations for the discontinuation of Local Seedling Suppliers (LSSs) after 2022 and the subsequent single-source procurement of approximately 11.1 million seedlings from Richie Plantations Limited for the 2023 and 2024 editions.

The Daily Graphic further requested copies of the relevant procurement documents, including the Ministry’s request to the Public Procurement Authority (PPA) and the Authority’s approval dated Mar. 2, 2023, authorising the single-source procurement.

The request also sought details of payments made to Richie Plantations, the average cost per seedling (including transportation), and copies of the relevant contracts and payment records.

In addition, the Ministry was asked to provide its official response to the Auditor-General’s finding that GH¢94,629,505.50 could potentially have been saved if the seedlings had been procured through Local Seedling Suppliers at approved Forestry Commission prices.

Screenshot of the RTI request submitted to the MLNR

Request referral

In a letter dated Aug. 28, 2026, the Ministry referred the request to the Forestry Commission for the necessary information.

The letter, signed by the Ministry’s Chief Director, Innocent Marcus Haligah, and addressed to the Chief Executive Officer of the Forestry Commission, requested that the information be submitted to the Ministry by Sept. 4, 2026.

It said the information was needed to enable the Ministry to respond to the applicant within the statutory period prescribed by the RTI Act, 2019 (Act 989).

However, despite the referral and subsequent follow-ups, the Ministry is yet to provide the requested information.

Screenshot of the RTI referral letter the MLNR submitted to the Forestry Commission 

Auditor-General’s findings

The request comes against the backdrop of concerns raised by the Auditor-General’s Performance Audit Report on the Management of the Green Ghana Project, 2021–2024, particularly over procurement costs, value for money and the treatment of local seedling suppliers.

The audit found that the Ministry moved away from engaging Local Seedling Suppliers in 2023 and 2024 and instead procured approximately 11.1 million seedlings from Richie Plantations Limited through a single-source arrangement.

According to the report, the government spent GH¢105.76 million on the seedlings at an average cost of GH¢9.50 each, comprising an average purchase price of GH¢5.50 and a transportation cost of GH¢4 per seedling.

The Auditor-General estimated that the government could have spent about GH¢11.13 million if the seedlings had been procured through Local Seedling Suppliers at the Forestry Commission’s approved prices, resulting in potential savings of GH¢94.63 million.

The report also found that 734 Local Seedling Suppliers remained unpaid for more than 16.1 million seedlings supplied during the 2021 and 2022 editions, with outstanding payments amounting to approximately GH¢39.55 million.

Ministry disputes audit findings

However, in its management response captured in the AG report (pages 61 -65) dated Mar. 31, 2026, the Ministry disputed several aspects of the audit findings, including the figures on seedling procurement and the costs involved.

The Ministry said the Forestry Commission had a combined target of 45 million seedlings between 2021 and 2024 but ultimately distributed and planted 57 million seedlings.

It gave annual figures of seven million seedlings in 2021, 26 million in 2022, 13 million in 2023, and 11 million in 2024.

The Ministry also disputed the prices cited in the audit, saying the Forestry Commission’s approved seedling prices ranged from GH¢1.50 to GH¢5, while the price of stumps was GH¢0.50.

It further said the PPA had approved a maximum price of GH¢6 per seedling, explaining that the amount covered the quality of the seedlings, transportation and direct delivery to planting sites.

On the discontinuation of Local Seedling Suppliers, the Ministry attributed the decision to outstanding debts owed to them for previous supplies and limited budgetary support.

It said the circumstances created a gap in seedling supply during the planting season, prompting the engagement of Richie Plantations to meet the demand.

The Ministry also acknowledged that although plans had been prepared for post-planting maintenance, funds were not released for the activities.

It said the Forestry Commission subsequently assigned some beneficiaries of the Youth in Afforestation and Reforestation Programme to undertake maintenance, but their numbers reduced significantly because of delays in the payment of allowances.

On seedling survival, the Ministry maintained that the project recorded an overall survival rate of between 62 and 82 per cent, describing the figure as a significant achievement.

It, however, acknowledged challenges in the project’s implementation and said it would take measures to strengthen post-planting maintenance and monitoring in subsequent projects.

Field findings

Despite the Ministry’s failure to provide the requested information, the Daily Graphic proceeded with its investigation, relying on available official records, field assessments and interviews with relevant stakeholders.

A field assessment in selected communities in the Upper East Region found that about 90 per cent of seedlings planted in parts of the Upper East Region under the Green Ghana Project have failed to survive.

A field tour of selected project sites, five years after the initiative was launched, revealed startling cases of seedling mismanagement, poor planting practices, and an overall lack of capacity to execute a project meant to make Ghana Green.

Contrary to the ministry’s claim that 60-80 per cent of the seedlings survived, independent checks show that of the 1,900 seedlings planted in three communities in the Upper East Region under the project, only 143 survived, a 7.5% survival rate.

Show More

Related Articles

Make a comment

Back to top button