Ghana

  • Election 2020: The first major test for Ghanaian fact-checkers and what to expect

    Ghana heads to the polls for its eighth democratic elections in the 4th Republic on December 7, 2020. 

    Over 17 million eligible voters are expected to participate in this exercise in 33,367 polling stations across the country. 

    Unlike previous elections, many have been awakened to the dangers of false information especially from the political class on the country’s democracy.  

    Previous elections have witnessed a number of false information including vile propaganda, malicious claims, and wild rumours, many of which spread so fast and likely influenced the polls. 

    With fact-checking steadily gaining roots in Ghana’s democratic space, there are great expectations that false information will be aggressively tackled during the electioneering period. 

    Dubawa Ghana has already formed important partnerships with the Coalition of Election Observers (CODEO), and the National Commission for Civic Education (NCCE) to police public discourse and ensure that the elections are conducted in a manner devoid of falsehoods, exaggerations and concocted stories. 

    Other fact-checkers, like Dubawa Ghana, have already produced many fact checks that have revealed the truth behind several public claims made by political actors. 

    This development must be highly appreciated as a necessity for the media in a growing democracy such as Ghana’s. 

    That notwithstanding, the work of fact-checkers will be put to serious test during the upcoming polls which, based on past experiences, will be characterized by a number of incidents that could make false information thrive. 

    This is a test because rigorous fact-checking is less than barely fours years old in Ghana and this is the first electioneering period being keenly followed by independent fact-checkers.     

    Considering some of the common incidents that have characterized election days in Ghana in the past, below are some of the common claims fact-checkers may have to deal with on December 7. 

    • The ballot box that got snatched: The thought of a ballot box being snatched at a polling station will not be strange to the ears of any Ghanaian political watcher. It is among the common incidents claimed to have happened during the country’s major elections. Due to high levels of mistrust for political opponents, such reports are easily believed by people who will not suffer themselves to verify, perhaps because it is very possible. Fact-checkers will be needed to look into such claims.
    • Violent clashes near or at a polling station: Ghana’s security agencies have identified some  6,178 communities as flashpoints for violence for this election. This was based on crime trends and incidents during previous elections. It, therefore, wouldn’t be hard to take in that violent clashes have occurred at a polling station within the identified areas. The fact that an area is noted for violence does not necessarily mean any claim of violence there is true. 
    • Discovery of hidden ballot papers: Often you’ll hear of claims about the discovery some thumb-printed ballot papers hidden somewhere. This may come up in making allegations of election fraud and has the potential discrediting the country’s polls. Fact-checkers can help to bring out the truth. Indeed, through the work of fact-checkers on such issues, followers could be better informed about relevant context, if any, and if the claim is even accurate or exaggerated.
    • ‘Unofficial’ results: As the world becomes more sophisticated, it has become easy to fake documents to prove anything. One can easily fall for this if due diligence, as done in the case by fact-checkers is not prioritized. People with malicious intents can manipulate photos of voter result sheets, known as pink sheets to give wrong results. 
    • The ‘recycled’ throwbacks: One of the common claims that will likely be seen will be the use of old images or videos and materials from other countries to make a case for something that is alleged to have happened at a polling station in real-time during the elections. Adding visual materials whether unrelated or old makes claims believable but not necessarily true. Fact-checkers again will help prove true or false such multimedia claims.  

    There are many other potential claims fact-checkers will encounter in covering the upcoming polls and they will need to diligently work their way to get the truth to an expectant audience.

    In the end, fact-checkers will greatly help to make the 2020 polls more credible and also further solidify their place in helping to instil truth in public discourse. 

  • Does the viral WhatsApp message claiming that our media devices and social media applications are being monitored in Ghana have any truth to it?

    Claim: A new communications regulation has been implemented to record phone calls and monitor social media applications use.

    False. The viral message making the rounds in Ghana is old with indications that it originated in another country. 

    Full Text:

    WhatsApp users have been warned of an impending monitoring exercise of various social media platforms and media devices. According to the message making rounds on WhatsApp, a new communications regulation has been implemented as of ‘today’ with focus on recording phone calls, and monitoring all social media applications like WhatsApp, Twitter,  and Facebook. Portions of the text reads,

    “Your devices are connected to ministry systems. Take care not to send unnecessary messages. Inform your children, relatives and friends about this to take care. ​​Don’t forward any posts or videos etc., you receive  regarding politics/present situation about Government/PM etc.​​ Police have put out a notification termed ..Cyber Crime … and action will be taken…just don’t delete …Inform your friends & others too. Writing or forwarding any msg on any political & religious debate is an offence now….arrest without warrant…This is very serious, plz let it be known to all our groups and individual members as group admin can be in deep trouble. Take care not to send unnecessary messages.Inform everyone about this to take care. Please share it; it’s very much true. Groups please be careful.”

    The message has also been shared on Facebook and other social media applications.

    Verification:

    Dubawa ran a google search using the contents of the message and discovered that this same message has, over some months now, been circulated on WhatsApp repeatedly and in various countries. The message has been translated and published in various languages but has the same content, that our telephones and social media are being monitored by the government.

    What has been done on the viral message so far?

    In March 2020, a fact check was done by thelogicalindian.com which revealed that the claim was false.

    The Wire has also published a fact check on this same message, declaring it false on April 7th, 2020.

    Source: thewire

    Dailyhunt also published a report on this same content and with the same findings, FAKE.

    PIB fact-check also also came out with the same conclusion in their report which was published on April 7th, 2020. 

    The baseline findings from these checks is that the End-to-End encryption and Secret message features of the WhatsApp and Facebook Application does not allow for such intrusions on person to person messaging.

    What is end-to-encryption?

    End-to-end encryption is applying encryption (the act of converting information or data into a code, especially to prevent unauthorized access) to messages on a device so that the only device that can decrypt it is the one it is sent to.

    Is end-to-end encryption full proof for privacy protection?

    Although it restricts transmitted data from anyone but the receiver of the message, it still has some limitations. It is possible for a third-party to know that a message was sent between the people involved, and if access is gained to the device, the content can also be read. 

    WhatsApp

    According to WhatApp,

    “WhatsApp’s end-to-end encryption is used when you message another person using WhatsApp Messenger. End-to-end encryption ensures only you and the person you’re communicating with can read or listen to what is sent, and nobody in between, not even WhatsApp. This is because with end-to-end encryption, your messages are secured with a lock, and only the recipient and you have the special key needed to unlock and read them. All of this happens automatically: no need to turn on settings or set up special secret chats to secure your messages.” 

    The End-to-end encryption on WhatsApp  safeguards users’ privacy with regards to sending and receiving messages. 

    Facebook

    In 2016, Facebook added another security feature which offers encryption enhancement in its Messenger application. The feature is called the “secret conversation”. This feature has to be activated by users as it is not a default setting like in the WhatsApp application. Messages are end-to-end encrypted with this feature as well.

    Has the government of Ghana announced a regulation of platforms?

    The Ghanaian government has not made an announcement to regulate phone calls through monitoring or recording and neither has the same been indicated for social media platforms. The Ministry of Communications has, however, passed the Cybersecurity Act to promote and regulate cybersecurity activities. 

    “The Law establishes the Cyber Security Authority, protects the critical information infrastructure of the country, regulates cybersecurity activities, provides for the protection of children on the internet and develops Ghana’s cybersecurity ecosystem.”

    Conclusion

    It is clear that the message being circulated in Ghana via WhatsApp did not originate locally and has made its rounds across countries before getting here. It has nothing to do with Ghana.

  • Profile of Christian Kwabena Andrew, flagbearer of GUM

    Christian Kwabena Andrew is the founder and 2020 flagbearer of the Ghana Union Movement (GUM) party.

    His party, GUM, which he formed in 2019 has a vision to revive Kwame Nkrumah’s developmental agenda for Ghana.

    Andrew was born in Duase Kanyasi in the Ashanti Region, and is 55 years old. He attended Ejisu Abankra elementary school, Ejisuman Senior Secondary School and Ejisu Atebubu Training College. He is a former teacher and former District Chief Officer.  Andrew is currently a businessman, entrepreneur, farmer, and pastor and founder of the  Life Assembly Worship Center. He is married to Princess Nyarko Andrew with three children.

    Andrew is one of the 12 presidential candidates, out of the 17 who filed nominations, who passed the qualification requirement by the Electoral Commission of Ghana. The rest are the two major political parties’ presidential candidates, Akufo-Addo and Mahama, nine other candidates of minority parties and an independent candidate.

  • Dr Bawumia on Mobile Money Interoperability: Two Claims Rated False

    During a one-on-one interview on Peace Fm’s Kokrooko on August 25th, 2020 between 54:56 to 55:06 minutes into the interview, the Vice President, Mahamadu Bawumia, made some claims about mobile money interoperability in Ghana and Africa as a whole.

    The Vice president stated emphatically that,

    “But the other part of it is that you have made the bank account and the mobile money wallet interoperable. So you can move money between the bank account and the mobile money wallet and vice versa and you can also do the same with the E-Zwich account. So triangular interoperability is what we have done. And Kwame this is the first country in Africa to do so. There is no other country in Africa that has been able to deliver mobile money interoperability.”

    During the interview, viewers and listeners contested the statement citing Kenya as a country that had also adopted mobile money interoperability.

    A video of the interview has been uploaded on Youtube.

    We look at the two claims made by Bawaumia: first, “there is no other country in Africa that has been able to deliver mobile money interoperability” and second, that Ghana is the only country in Africa to implement interoperability between bank account and mobile money wallets.

    What is mobile money operability?

    This is a service that allows direct and seamless transfer of money from one mobile money wallet to another across networks.

    Over time, this has grown to include integration in broader payment infrastructures, connecting a variety of financial services providers.

    In this regard, there is a move from restricted transactions between just mobile money providers (MMPs) and one that offers the added opportunity for transfers or transactions between  two accounts, like MMPs and a bank.

    According to the report published by GSMA, 

    “Of the 95 markets where mobile money services are live, 48 have interoperability with either a bank or MMPs…On average, mobile money providers with bank integrations are connected to 13 banks.”

    Claim 1: No country in Africa has been able to deliver mobile money interoperability.

    Verdict: Ghana is not the only country to adopt and deliver on money interoperability. 

    Dubawa ran an online check for African countries who have functioning mobile money interoperability and found that many African countries, for instance, Kenya, Uganda, Tanzania and others have adopted and implemented the mobile money interoperability. 

    Quartz Africa in 2018 reported Tanzania to be the leading country in delivering interoperability. However, this level of operability is limited to Mobile money providers.

    “Indeed, there’s precedent in Tanzania, the first African country to adopt interoperability, where there has been increased transactions among users. It’s a measure that’s also been adopted in Kenya and Ghana,” the report reads.

    On June 4th, 2014, The East African also published a report on Tanzania being the first African country to implement the interoperability system. 

    Further search also led to GSM Association, an organisation that represents the interest of mobile network operators worldwide.

    GSMA released a report titled “Tracking the journey towards mobile money interoperability Emerging evidence from six markets: Tanzania, Pakistan, Madagascar, Ghana, Jordan and Uganda” in June 2020.

    The report was based on  a study using a mixed-method analysis  which included 32 key informant interviews, both remote and in-country, as well as desk research and field interviews conducted between December 2019 and February 2020. 

    It provides detailed insight into the state of mobile money operability in the selected countries and some limited information on others. See below.

    Image source: GSMA

    Claim 2: “There is no interoperability between bank account and the mobile money wallet anywhere in Africa…”

    Verdict: Other countries, Tanzania for instance, have mobile money wallet to bank account  interoperability which has been and is currently in use.

    Dr Bawumia in responding to the host’s comment that other countries, including Kenya, have implemented interoperability said Ghana is the only African country to implement interoperability with banks inclusive (1:38:30 to 1:39:48).

    This claim is false. Dubawa found information available that points to the fact that other African countries, for instance Tanzania, have mobile money wallet to bank account transfer services available. 

    Tanzania has platforms that link and allow funds transfer from mobile wallet to bank accounts and even to wallets and accounts outside their country. In some cases, aggregators serve as a link between these accounts. Selcom, Craftsilicon or Cellantis are examples of such platforms that enable such transfers.

    Dubawa further spoke to Victor Makere, Head of Digital Banking, Standard Chartered Bank, Tanzania, who explained that indeed mobile money wallet to bank account transfers are done in Tanzania in two ways. 

    The first way (Direct Integration between Mobile Network Operator and Bank) requires the bank to have a wallet with the mobile network provider. The second option is similar but between the bank account  and MNO there is an aggregator.”

    This was corroborated in another conversation with Emmanuel Mwinuka, Chief Information Officer (CIO), Absa Tanzania. He explained that mobile money wallet to bank account interoperability is functional in Tanzania. 

    He further indicated that there is a plan to launch a project called “Tanzania Instant Payment System (TIPS)” which will create a platform that supports instant centralised settlement between MNOs and bank accounts, bank accounts and MNOs and MNOs to other MNOs. This project will eventually fade out the existing interoperability systems that are in place, promoting ease. 

    Based only on the statement made by the vice president, this claim is false.

    Conclusion

    Ghana is not the first or only country to deliver on mobile money interoperability. It is also not the only African country to implement triangular interoperability.

  • As politics takes the limelight; a look into the current state of the COVID-19 pandemic.

    With the dying interest in stories regarding coronavirus in Ghana at a time that the country’s preparations for elections are getting into high gear, not much is in the news about the pandemic ravaging the world. As periodic information about the global disaster remains important for most aspects of public and private life, here is an update.

    According to the World Health Organisation (WHO), the global confirmed case count for the Covid-19 pandemic currently rests at 18,902,735 as at August 7 with a death toll of 709,511 across 216 countries, areas and territories.

    Updates from Worldometer, on the other hand, reports that the global death toll for the COVID-19 pandemic is now at 721,857 as at August 7, 2020, with 19,477,842 confirmed cases presently. 

    Although the data varies slightly, it is clear that there is an increase in cases across the world. All is not lost however as 12,025,753 recoveries have also been recorded worldwide.

    In Ghana specifically, infections continue to rise as confirmed counts reach 40,097  as of August 7, 2020, according to reports on the Ghana Health Service (GHS) website.

    Recoveries and discharges are also at 36,638 and 206 deaths.  It is important to note that recoveries and discharges do not correlate even though reported as if they do. This is to say that an individual may be discharged without necessarily having recovered from the virus. This is because of the new discharge policy in effect since June 2020.

    As stated by the President in his latest and 14th address to the nation on Covid-19, more and more restrictions have been eased in the country in the bid to restore some normalcy. All these changes are to take place with continued adherence to safety protocols.

    Here are some of the changes:

    • Increase in church service duration from one to two hours and the restriction on the number of congregants worshipping at a time has been lifted as of August 1, 2020. This is to say that there is no limit to the number of congregants to be present in worship centres henceforth. However, the safety protocols, social distancing, mask-wearing, and handwashing and sanitizer usage remain. Well-ventilated service spaces are prescribed for worship periods. 
    • Opening of tourist destinations and open air drinking spots sites excluding nightclubs, pubs and the like.
    • Full capacity in transport vehicles like taxis, buses etc

    See more here.

    Conclusion:

    COVID-19 is still an ongoing threat to every individual, regardless of age, colour, social status, or nationality, thus making the need for constant update essential, even as the country prepares for general elections. 

  • FALSE; President Akufo-Addo did not caution Ghanaians against a COVID-19 plan by Rockefeller Foundation

    President Akufo-Addo has, in an audiotape, warned Ghanaians of a Coronavirus plan reported in an article by the Rockefeller Foundation.

    The speaker in the audio is not President Akufo-Addo. Although a document published by the Rockefeller Foundation in May 2010 with a chapter titled ‘Lockstep’ was found, the chapter does not contain the exact content read by the speaker in the audio. 

    Full text

    The conspiracies surrounding COVID-19 do not seem to be tailing off, as a 14-minute audio purported to be from the President of Ghana, Akufo-Addo, warns Ghanaians to pay attention to an alleged extract from an article titled ‘Rockefeller Lockstep 2010’ on the Rockefeller website. 

    In the audio, the speaker’s main claim is on the Rockefeller Foundation’s detailing of a simulated global outbreak, the required steps involved, the various phases required, the overall timeline and the expected outcomes.

    Some of the plans and phases the speaker purports to be from the article include: 

    1.The creation of morbid viruses such as SARS, MERS and HIV in a laboratory to be stolen and smuggled to Wuhan, China as a pandemic.

    2. The Foundation’s plans to fund organisations such as WHO, CDC and the UN

    3. The creation and funding of a vaccination development plan, vaccination verification certification protocols, digital IDs to enforce the vaccination program after the mandatory rollout is enacted

    4. The control of a depopulation agenda 

    5. The establishment of public quarantine to destroy regions’ economy

    6. The creation of civil unrest, breakdown of supply chain to cause the start of mass food shortages, as well as weaken immune systems due to lack of interaction.

    The speaker further requested for the audio to be passed around to create awareness so that the document can be pulled down from the Rockefeller website.

    The audio circulating is accompanied by a message which reads:

    THIS VERY IMPORTANT SECRET AUDIOTAPE BY THE PRESIDENT OF GHANA MUST BE CIRCULATED TO THE ENTIRE HUMANITY FOR EXTREME AWARENESS OF THE CORONAVIRUS PLOT

    Verification

    The speaker in the audio

    It is evident that the voice of the speaker in the audio is not that of President Akufo-Addo. Yet, Dubawa further contacted the spokesperson for the President of Ghana, Eugene Arhin, who could not be reached yet. Additionally, Dubawa has contacted the Ministry of Information and awaiting a response.

    President Akufo-Addo has made no official announcements in any publication or on any platform concerning such a matter. Rather, he continues to publicly update Ghanaians on measures and efforts by the government to contain the spread of the virus.

    The content of Lockstep 2010

    Dubawa found a 54-page pdf document titled Scenarios for the Future of Technology and International Development – a report produced by the Rockefeller Foundation and the Global Business Network, published in May 2010.

    The document focuses on how technology can help in globalisation by using scenario planning to develop strategies to respond to each scenario over a period of years.

    On page 18 of the document, which contains that chapter on the ‘Lockstep’ as a Scenario Narrative, the document indicates the LockStep to be ‘a world of tighter top-down government control and authoritarian leadership with limited innovation and growing citizen pushback’. 

    It predicts and narrates a global pandemic expected in 2012, which would affect world economies and international mobility of persons. It is also expected to affect industries such as tourism and break global supply chains. Locally, the global pandemic is also expected to affect shops and buildings by keeping them empty of supplies for months. The chapter also predicts how the most pandemic-prepared and developed countries would be overwhelmed, as countries such as America would be unable to contain the spread whereas China would have a quick and effective enforcement of mandatory quarantine for its citizens. 

    The global pandemic is also predicted to result in mandatory wearing of face masks, body temperature checks at communal spaces, and states that Ghana’s government would have ambitious programmes to improve basic infrastructure and ‘ensure the availability of clean water for all her people’ which would lead to ‘a sharp decline in water-borne diseases’. 

    It stipulates that people would grow weary of so much top-down control and letting leaders and authorities make choices for them to the extent that there would be protests. It further predicts that developed countries would have innovations and technology whereas developing countries’ access to technology would remain limited.

    It finalises the import of this narrative and provides timelines for the occurrences from 2010 to 2030. 

    Photo source: Rockefeller Foundation document

    Although the Rockefeller 2010 Lockstep chapter Dubawa accessed contains simulations on a hypothesised global pandemic with indicated timelines with the purpose of using technology to enforce governmental control on citizens, the chapter does not reveal the exact claims made by the speaker in the audio, unless such claims are otherwise contained in another similar document. 

    It is, however, certain that the speaker is not the president of Ghana.

    Conclusion

    The claim that the president of Ghana has cautioned Ghanaians of a Coronavirus plan by the Rockefeller Foundation is false. President Akufo-Addo has made no official pronouncement or publication of such announcements to Ghanaians.

    Also, even though the Rockefeller Foundation document containing the 2010 Lockstep chapter simulates a global pandemic and predicts its global effects, the content is not the same as the claims the speaker makes in the viral audio. 

  • What you Need to Know About Demolition of the Nigerian High Commission in Ghana

    Over the weekend, social media users in and out of Ghana were outraged over the news of the demolition of the Nigerian High Commission in Ghana, which according to the reports, happened on the night of Friday, June 19th. While some claimed that the High Commission itself had been demolished by armed men others said it was a building belonging to the Commission which had been pulled down

    1. The Building which was demolished

    Dubawa contacted the Nigerian High Commission which clarified that the demolished property was not the chancery but a building in the Commissioner’s Diplomatic Residence. 

    “It’s actually not the chancery. It’s actually one of our quarters, a building around the diplomatic residence…It is not the Embassy itself”, a staff of the Nigerian High Commission confirmed.

    Although both properties are located at Ridge in Accra, the Embassy is located behind the High Commissioner’s residence.

    2. Official Reactions from Nigeria

    Nigeria’s Minister of Foreign Affairs, Geoffrey Onyeama, through his official Twitter account, condemned the attack. 

    “We strongly condemn two outrageous criminal attacks in Accra, #Ghana, on a residential building in our diplomatic premises by unknown persons in which a bulldozer was used to demolish the building,” Mr Onyeama tweeted. “We are engaging the Ghanaian Government and demand urgent action to find the perpetrators and provide adequate protection for Nigerians and their property in Ghana…”

    3. Ghana apologises and says demolition “not a government-sanctioned activity” 

    According to a tweet from the Nigerian Presidency, President Akufo-Addo has, in a telephone call to President Muhammadu Buhari of Nigeria, apologised to the Nigerian government and indicated that the incident is under investigation. 

    The Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Ghana, had, a few hours after the news broke, apologised and denounced the attack which it says violates the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations which states:

    “1. The premises of the mission shall be inviolable. The agents of the receiving State may not enter them, except with the consent of the head of the mission. 

    2. The receiving State is under a special duty to take all appropriate steps to protect the premises of the mission against any intrusion or damage and to prevent any disturbance of the peace of the mission or impairment of its dignity. 

    3. The premises of the mission, their furnishings and other property thereon and the means of transport of the mission shall be immune from search, requisition, attachment or execution.”

    According to a press release by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, investigations are currently underway to bring out the facts of the matter and bring the culprits to book. The Ministry further assured the international community of Ghana’s commitment to ensuring the safety of members of the Diplomatic corps. 

    “The Ministry wishes to reassure the Diplomatic Community in Ghana and the Nigerian High Commission in particular, that Ghana remains a law-abiding country that upholds the principle of the rule of law, where due process is followed at all times. The government will, therefore, not relent in its primary obligation to guarantee the safety of Members of the Diplomatic Corp in Ghana” the Ministry said.

    Ghana’s Minister of Foreign Affairs and Regional Integration, Shirley Ayorkor Botchway, on a visit to the Commission on Monday, also said the incident was “not a government-sanctioned activity”.

    4. Controversies around ownership of the land

    The Paramount Chief of the Osu Traditional Area and the President of the Greater Accra Regional House of Chiefs, Nii Okwei Kinka Dowuona VI, has stated through a letter to Ghanaian Media houses, that the land on which the building was being put up on belongs to them, and therefore was being trespassed upon.

    “The said parcel of land and the entire Osu Mantse layout is not State Land but is a part of Osu Paramount Stool land and as such it is only the Stool that has the mandate to grant lease be it expired or otherwise,” the statement reads.

    “The said parcel of land is separate from that which is currently being occupied by the Nigerian High Commission,” it added.

    The statement further claims the structure was being put up by a Nigerian businessman with the help of the Nigerian High Commission for use as “an events center for commercial purposes and is not a block of flats as has been purported in the reportage.”

    Ms Botchway, however, indicated that even if ownership of the land is in dispute, it is expected that “the persons go to court because that is the normal way of dealing with such matters in this country.”

    The details that remain unclear presently is whether or not the portion of the High Commissioners Compound on which this structure was being erected constitutes the Commission’s land or the land owned by the Osu Stool. 

    The latter could constitute a breach of Article 41(3) of the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations which states that, 

    “The premises of the mission must not be used in any manner incompatible with the functions of the mission as laid down in the present Convention or by other rules of general international law or by any special agreements in force between the sending and the receiving State.” 

    Same goes for Article 12 of the convention which also states that, 

    “The sending State may not, without the prior express consent of the receiving State, establish offices forming part of the mission in localities other than those in which the mission itself is established.”

  • Is Ghana among countries with one of the highest numbers of COVID-19 tests in Africa?

    Ghana has one of the highest numbers of tests conducted for COVID-19 on the African continent -President Akufo-Addo 

    An official from WHO Ghana has confirmed Ghana to be among African countries testing in high numbers on the continent. Furthermore, available data for eleven other African countries in comparison with Ghana, also prove this assertion to be true.

    Full text

    Health experts have shown the importance of testing for COVID-19 in order to help isolate or hospitalize and treat infected people, as well as to help identify the prevalence, spread and contagiousness of the virus in the community. 

    It is in this light that in a recent update on measures taken to combat the spread of Coronavirus, President Akufo-Addo stated the government of Ghana’s efforts to reduce the number of cases through tracing, testing and treating. 

    He highlighted that the total number of tests conducted in Ghana as at 13 June 2020, was 254, 331- a number which he stated was one of the highest on the African continent, especially in relation to Ghana’s population of 31 million. 

    Verification

    Dubawa spoke to an official from the WHO office in Ghana who confirmed the claim:

    “Oh yes, Ghana is one of the countries testing high numbers in Africa’’

    News reports here, here, here, reveal that testing rates in Africa are generally low as most African countries were not conducting tests for COVID-19 due to a number of constraints.  

    Yet, for some that were testing, Dubawa found data available on the total tests conducted as at 13 June 2020 for the following twelve African countries, with their corresponding population. 

    This is because, experts here, here, here, here indicate that the population of a country is a factor considered to indicate a country’s testing rate.

    CountryTotal tests conducted as of 13 June 2020 PopulationTests Per 1000 population(test/(population/1000))
    Mauritius142,8891,271,768112.354
    Djibouti40,855 988,00041.351
    South Africa1,087,88759,308,69018.342
    Ghana254,33131,072,9408.184
    Rwanda87,65612,952,2186.767
    Tunisia59,88711,818,6195.067
    Senegal60,28616,743,9274.654
    Uganda125,49145,741,0072.743
    Kenya112,17153,771,2962.086
    Zimbabwe24,01014,862,9241.615
    Ethiopia176,504114,963,5881.535
    Nigeria90,464206,139,5890.438

    Source of country tests without hyperlinks: Our world in data
    Source of country tests with hyperlinks: National sites for each country
    Source of country population: Worldometer

    Based on available data as of 13 June 2020 on the above twelve African countries, the testing rates show that Ghana is among the countries with high total tests conducted in Africa.

    Conclusion

    The President of Ghana’s statement that Ghana’s total tests conducted (254,331) for COVID-19 as at 13 June, 2020 is one of the highest on the African continent is true. 

    Ghana ranks 4th out of 12 African countries with available figures on testing of citizens. An official from the World Health Organisation in Ghana has confirmed that Ghana is among countries in Africa testing high numbers. 

    Moreover, available data from eleven other African countries prove this assertion.

  • FACT-CHECK: Was a tribute read on Ghana’s behalf at George Floyd’s funeral?

    A tribute was read on behalf of Ghana and President Akufo-Addo at George Floyd’s funeral in the US.

    No tribute was read on either Ghana or President Nana Akufo-Addo’s behalf at the funeral service of George Floyd in the US. However, the country and its president were acknowledged for the solidarity shown to the family of Floyd.

    Full text

    Some social media posts shared by some influential persons claim that a tribute was read on behalf of Ghana and on the personal behalf of President Nana Akufo-Addo at the funeral service of African-American man, George Floyd, that was held at the Fountain of Praise Church in Houston, Texas on Tuesday, June 9, 2020.

    One of the posts reads: “Tribute read on behalf of @nakufoaddo and Ghana at the funeral of #georgefloyd.” Another read, “Tribute read on behalf of Ghana at the ongoing funeral for #georgefloyd.”

    The posts, accompanied by a one-minute-long video clip from the funeral, have reached thousands of social media users already. 

    Verification

    To verify the claim, we obtained a full video clip of the funeral service as streamed on Facebook by Yahoo News and reviewed the part that mentioned Ghana and President Nana Akufo-Addo. 

    At the one hour eight-minute mark, Ivy McGregor, Director for Social Responsibility for Parkwood Entertainment, was invited to deliver “resolutions”. 

    She read resolutions from Fountain of Praise Church, Greater St. Matthew Baptist Church, and the 1993 Class of Jack Yates Senior High School. 

    At 1 hour 14 minutes, she mentioned Ghana and President Nana Akufo-Addo. We have transcribed all she said about Ghana and President Nana Akufo-Addo below.

    [At 1:14:00 to 1:15:00]

    Ivy McGregor: “The family of George Floyd will like to acknowledge the message of solidarity, resolution and virtual tribute from His Excellency Nana Akufo-Addo, the President of Ghana. Yesterday, during the memorial, a video produced by the people of Ghana was broadcast for thousands of mourners as they paid their final respects to Mr Floyd. The family is honoured by President Akufo-Addo’s decision to have Mr Floyd’s name permanently mounted on the historic Sankofa wall at the Diaspora African Forum in the W.E.B Dubois centre in Africa.

    They are grateful that the country of Ghana stands with the Floyd family and the struggle of all families to change the status quo of racism and prejudice. The family is deeply moved by the generous act of the Ghanaian government to solidify George Floyd’s legacy.”

    McGregor subsequently acknowledged several individuals and institutions who had also expressed their solidarity with George Floyd. 

    To give a better context, we have defined the two keywords in this fact-check; Tribute and Resolution below: 

    Tribute: A tribute is a sign of respect or admiration, an award to honour a person’s accomplishments (according to Vocabulary.com).

    Resolution: A funeral resolution is a formal acknowledgement of the relationship between the deceased and a church community. It is delivered at a funeral to honour someone who has died by elaborating on his spiritual qualities and good works (according to dying.lovetoknow.com).

    Based on the above, it is clear that Ivy McGregor did not read a tribute on behalf of Ghana or on behalf of President Nana Akufo-Addo. She read three resolutions from different groups and only acknowledged Ghana and President Akufo-Addo for the solidarity for George Floyd and his family.

    Based on these facts, we conclude that the claim is false.  

  • Is the Failure to Wear A Mask In Public Places A Criminal Offence in Ghana?

    Not wearing a mask in public places is a criminal offence – viral social media messages

    The viral WhatsApp message is legislation issued on 6 April 2020 in Kenya for offenders who contravene the rule to properly wear masks in public places. Neither the government of Ghana nor any mainstream media in Ghana have so far communicated such information. 

    Full text

    Subsequent to the lifting of the partial lockdown by the president of Ghana, Akufo-Addo, the government announced enhanced measures to control the spread of the Coronavirus in Ghanaian communities. One of such measures includes the wearing of nose masks by citizens in public places. This measure has further been enforced with a compulsory ‘No Mask, No Entry’ policy in public places by the Greater Accra Regional Minister, Ishmael Ashitey, in a press statement and by authorities in other parts of the country. 

    A viral message circulating on WhatsApp and other platforms in the country takes this further. It states that failure to wear a mask in public places is a criminal offence liable to a fine of 20,000 or 6-month imprisonment or both. The full message reads:

    “It has finally been gazetted. Failure to wear a mask while in a Public place is actually a criminal offence. Section 6(1)(b) as read with section 11 of the Regulations. If found guilty you can be liable to a fine of 20,000/= or imprisonment for 6 months or both. Failure to wear a mask in a public or private transport and public transport operators Section 5(4) must wear mask. So don’t say you were not warned. Share widely with friends so that they should not leave the house without a mask. Public place means stepping outside your house. So, take precautions.”

    Verification

    Dubawa found that the same post has been shared on Facebook with comments indicating that the message originates from Kenya. 

    Further checks show the legislation was enacted in Kenya and not Ghana as the messages sought to suggest.

    Google checks revealed that Kenyan media outlets here, here, and here published articles on the penalty of not wearing face masks between 9 and 15 April 2020.

    Their publications indicated that the Kenyan government had issued a gazette stating that citizens were required to wear a proper nose mask that covers their mouth and nose. Anyone who contravened the rules was considered to have committed an offence liable to a fine not exceeding 20,000 shillings, imprisonment not exceeding 6-months or both. 

    Dubawa further found a copy of the Kenya Gazette Supplement No 41, a special issue on 6 April 2020, which according to some Kenyan media here, here was signed by the Health Cabinet Secretary, Mutahi Kagwe. 

    The photo below shows the section of the Kenya Gazette which states: the rule to wear a proper nose mask to cover both nose and mouth (4), an act of offence if it is contravened (5) and the penalty of a fine not exceeding 20, 000 shilling, imprisonment not exceeding 6 months or both if the offence is committed (11)

    Screenshot of the legislation found online

    Dubawa also noted that the viral WhatsApp message purported to be a new legislation in Ghana states the fine of 20, 000 and does not include the currency of Ghana (cedis) to it. 

    Meanwhile, the government of Ghana has not issued any official statement to communicate this purported new legislation on the penalty of not wearing masks in public places. Neither has any mainstream Ghanaian media published on such information.

    Conclusion

    The viral message circulating on Ghanaian WhatsApp outlets threatening to fine and or imprison offenders who fail to wear masks in public places is misleading. The message is new legislation on a Public Health Act against Coronavirus in Kenya, issued on 6 April 2020. Neither the government of Ghana nor Ghanaian mainstream media have conveyed any such information to citizens. Nonetheless, though the failure to wear masks may not be a criminal offence in Ghana, Ghana still has a compulsory ‘No Mask, No Entry’ directive for entering public places, to help control the spread of the virus in the county.

Back to top button